The Hidden Cost of Hypercompetence

By Dr. Jordan Wolfsohn

Authenticity is one of the most overlooked, if not outright minimized, ways of being in professional life. It tends to be treated as a personality trait, something a person either has or does not, rather than as a way of relating to oneself that carries real consequences for health and functioning.

In our work, we see those consequences regularly. They rarely arrive labeled as a problem with authenticity. More often they show up as exhaustion, irritability, problems at work, or a vague sense that something is off and hard to name. This piece looks at how that happens, what the research suggests, and what psychotherapy can offer.

A Pattern

Someone is making their way through life, well regarded, finding moments or periods of success, and others rely on them. They may be a physician, an attorney, a founder, or a parent holding a household together. Over the years they have learned to present a composed or hypercompetent version of themselves, often without knowing that they do so or how.

When they come to therapy, the concern is rarely the work itself. It is a fatigue that rest does not seem to fix, and a sense of managing themselves throughout the day. Some clients have described this as feeling like they are always on, even at home. Others struggle to separate their own natural way of being from how they are expected to perform in the role of the moment.

What stands out is how reasonable this way of being once was. The composed self usually developed for good reasons, often early in life, as a way of staying connected, earning approval, or keeping things steady when they were not. It worked, and that is part of why it is so hard to see.

What happens outside of awareness

Much of that fatigue, the experience of a drain on resources, comes from the effort of monitoring how one comes across and adjusting to what they expect others need. Because so much of this happens outside of awareness, people often feel the cost long before they can see the cause.

This is a central idea in what we have come to understand differentiates generic from more useful therapy. Recurring patterns, expectations of ourselves and others, the ways we navigate the world; they all develop over time and often are so automatic, we cannot be fully aware of it all. A person does not decide each morning to appear unflappable. The pattern runs on its own, and it shapes what they notice, what they say, and what they allow themselves to feel.

That is to say, the effort is real even when it is invisible. It draws on the same resources needed for focus, sound judgment, and recovery. Over time, people may find themselves depleted without a clear explanation, and they often conclude that they simply need to try harder.

What the research suggests

The research is consistent with what we see clinically. A meta-analysis of 95 studies and more than 23,000 participants found that surface acting, faking or suppressing emotions at work, was associated with higher rates of burnout and physical symptoms of stress.

Other studies look at the same question from the opposite direction. A meta-analysis of 75 studies and more than 36,000 participants found a meaningful positive relationship between authenticity and both wellbeing and engagement, across ages, genders, and settings. In a study that followed more than 1,200 employees over six months, those who felt more authentic at work later reported stronger work ability and fewer depressive symptoms. Research with working adults has also found that self-alienation, the sense of being cut off from one's own experience, is among the strongest predictors of poorer wellbeing at work.

It is worth being careful with these findings. Most of this research relies on self-report and shows association rather than cause, and the relationship appears to run in both directions. People who are doing better may also find it easier to be authentic. Though we will likely never know which came first, the chicken or the egg, the overall picture is consistent. Showing up as oneself is linked to less of the drain that so often brings people to therapy, and to do that, one must learn what that is for themselves.

What authenticity is and is not

Authenticity in this sense does not mean disclosing everything or setting aside professional judgment. A surgeon still needs steadiness in the operating room, and a parent still decides what a child needs to hear. Rather, it means reducing the distance between what a person experiences internally and how they operate day to day.

It also does not mean abandoning the competent self. That self is often a real strength. The difficulty comes when it becomes the only available way of being, when it is maintained even in places where it is not needed, and when the person loses contact with what lies underneath it.

When that distance narrows, less energy goes toward self-management, and more is available for the work and for life. People often describe this as feeling more like themselves, more present with others, and less tired in a way they had stopped noticing. For many of the people psychotherapists work with, this supports both wellbeing and performance across roles.

What therapy can offer

Because these patterns operate largely outside of awareness, they are difficult to change through effort or advice alone. Telling someone to be more authentic tends to become one more standard to meet, and one more thing to manage.

Psychotherapy offers something different. It creates a setting where a person can begin to notice the patterns as they happen, particularly in the relationship with the therapist. Over time, people come to understand where the composed self came from, what it protects them from, and what it costs. That understanding is often what creates room for change.

A careful assessment at the outset matters here. It helps distinguish this kind of chronic depletion from depression, anxiety, or other conditions that call for a different focus, and it shapes treatment around the individual rather than a general protocol. For people carrying significant responsibility, the work is less about learning new techniques and more about recovering access to their own experience.

Closing thoughts

People caught in patterns that don’t serve them are usually not short on effort or capability. Much of both is going toward maintaining a way of being that developed for understandable reasons and no longer serves them the way it once did. Bringing that into awareness does not undo it on its own, but it makes it possible to respond differently, and over time that tends to show up in how a person feels, relates to others, and works.

Sources

  • Emmerich, A. I., and Rigotti, T. (2017). Reciprocal relations between work related authenticity and intrinsic motivation, work ability and depressivity. Frontiers in Psychology.

  • Hülsheger, U. R., and Schewe, A. F. (2011). On the costs and benefits of emotional labor. Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, 16(4), 361–389.

  • Shedler, J. (2010). The efficacy of psychodynamic psychotherapy. American Psychologist, 65(2), 98–109.

  • Sutton, A. (2020). Living the good life. A meta-analysis of authenticity, well-being and engagement. Personality and Individual Differences, 153.

  • van den Bosch, R., and Taris, T. W. (2014). The authentic worker's well-being and performance. The Journal of Psychology.

Next
Next

Couples Therapy for High-Performing Leaders: The Connection Between Relationship Health and Leadership